Travel Features

The Tombstone in the Lake: Uncovering the History of Cemetery Island

October 28, 2025 | Lakin' It with Lydia

A tombstone sticking out of the water in the middle of Kentucky Lake? It sounds like a local legend, but it’s absolutely real. Every fall, as the lake level drops for winter pool, this lonely marker becomes visible, causing many to wonder: Was someone buried there because they wanted to be in the lake?

The truth is, Kentucky Lake hasn't always been here; it’s a flooded Tennessee River valley. When the Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) created the lake, they had to relocate everything—entire homes, towns, and even graveyards, including the Newburg Cemetery.

This cemetery originally held 28 known graves. The TVA moved 23 of those to a nearby location, but five were left behind. It’s possible that the families specifically requested their loved ones not be moved. Today, only one of those five graves is marked: the tombstone of John Whaley, who was buried here in 1907.

During the summer, this spot is marked by a flag, helping boaters avoid hitting the stone. Despite the warning, it happens often, and someone usually steps in to re-erect the marker. Seeing John Whaley’s tombstone is a powerful, physical reminder that beneath the beautiful waters of Kentucky Lake lies a rich history of communities and lives that existed long before the dam was built.

If you decide to visit the graves, be respectful. You can rent a boat from Lynnhurst Family resort and then follow the directions:



Here is a video about "Cemetary Island":

< More Features & News